Comparative analysis of cooperation ‘factors for asthma patients
Abstract
One of the most important tasks of the up-to-date medicine is to achieve a high level of cooperation (compliance) between, a patient and healthcare initiatives. Majority of compliance evaluation methods are medical regimen oriented. Meanwhile a treatment progress is a complex of healthcare initiatives. Besides that at present time compliance evaluation does not consider availability of healthcare initiatives.
The target of this article is to analyze medical and social factors influencing the index of cooperation (IC) for asthma patients. IC is wider (than compliance) concept featuring level of a patient's desire and possibility to follow all doctor’s recommendations.
For IC evaluation ICBA-50 questionnaire was used. It contains 50 questions assessing IC in accordance with 8 main criteria. Seventy three asthmatic out-patients were involved in this study.
It was established that a total IC (TIC) for the asthmatic patients was 65.66±1.60%. The most strong TIC correlation (p<0.001) was revealed for the patients’ initial cooperation level (InC), comprehension of a danger (CD), a level of knowledge (KN) and a level of the patients’ satisfaction with the cooperation (S).
A positive correlation was determined between TIC and objective spirometry data: % FEV1 and % PEF (p<0.05), and subjective asthma controllability level (p<0.01). A positive correlation was also defined between TIC and the patients’ age (pcO.001), gender (p<0.01), educational level (p<0.05), occupation (p<0.05), marital status (p<0.01), number of family members (p<0.01), family income (p<0.05), and number of family members suffering from asthma (p<0.05). A negative correlation between TIC and smoking index (p<0.0l), asthma duration (p<0.001), and asthma treatment expenditures (p<0.01) was established.
The current results allow to determine necessary doctor’s actions directed to the optimization of the cooperation with patients according to his medical and social status.
About the Authors
N. A. BushuevaRussian Federation
N. Yu. Senkevich
Russian Federation
A. S. Belevsky
Russian Federation
A. G. Chuchalin
Russian Federation
References
1. Сенкевич Н.Ю. Гуманистические принципы ведения бронхиальной астмы / / Пульмонология- 1999.- Прил.: Бронхиальная астма. Формулярная система. (Руководство для врачей России).- С.34-40.
2. Сенкевич Н.Ю., Белевский А.С. Качество жизни — предмет научных исследований в пульмонологии / / Тер. арх.- 2000.- № 3 - С.36-41.
3. Сенкевич Н.Ю., Белевский А.С., Бушуева Н.А. Оценка индекса кооперации больных бронхиальной астмой / / 9-й Национальный конгресс по болезням органов дыхания: Тез.- М., 1999 - N2 I. С.161.
4. Сенкевич Н.Ю. Человек и лекарство: предпосылки к кооперации / / Ремедиум.- 2000.- № 5.- С.56-61.
5. Chemlik F., Doughty A. Objective measurements of compliance in asthma treatment / /Ann. Allergy.- 1994.- Vol.73.- P.527-532.
6. Cochrane G.M. Compliance in asthma: a European perspective / / Eur. Respir. J - 1995 - Vol.10, № 5 - P.l 16-119.
7. Cochrane G.M. Compliance in asthma / / Eur. Respir. Rev.- 1998- Vol.8, No 56 - P.239-242.
8. Harding J.M., Modell M. How patients manage asthma / / J. Roy. Coll. Gen. Pract. — 1985.- Vol.35- P.226-228.
9. James P.N., Anderson J.B., Prior J.G. et al. Patterns of drug taking in patients with chronic airflow obstruction / / Postgrad. Med. J - 1985 - Vol.61- P.7-10.
10. Jarvis M.J. Psychological profile of complier versus noncomplier / / Eur. Respir. Rev - 1998 - Vol. 8, № 56.- P.250-254.
11. Jones P.W. Health status, quality of life and compliance / / Ibid.- P.243-246.
12. Kinsman R A., Dirks J.F., Dahlem N.W. Noncompliance to prescribed-as-needed medication use in asthma: usage patterns and patient characteristics / / J. Psychosom. Res.- 1980.- Vol.24.- P.97-101.
13. Kleiger J.H., Jones N.F. Characteristics of alexithymic patients in chronic respiratory illness population / / J. Nerv. Ment. Dis.- 1980 - Vol. 168 - P.465-470.
14. Senkevich N., Belevsky A., Chuchalin A. General motivation — situation model of compliance development in .asthma / / European Respiratory Society. Annual Congress: Abstracts.- Madrid, 1999 - № 3334.
15. Wilson S.R., Scamagas P., German D.F. A controlled trial of two forms of self-management education for adults with asthma / / Am. J. Med - 1993 - Vol.94 - P.564-576.
Review
For citations:
Bushueva N.A., Senkevich N.Yu., Belevsky A.S., Chuchalin A.G. Comparative analysis of cooperation ‘factors for asthma patients. PULMONOLOGIYA. 2000;(3):53-61. (In Russ.)